Payroll Companies For Small Business: A Guide To Choosing The Best One
by Piyasa Mukhopadhyay Small Business 20 June 2025
Having a small business is exciting, but payroll isn’t. It can be challenging to monitor hours, track taxes, and ensure that employees are paid on time. Due to this, most small businesses utilize payroll companies to assist them with their payroll needs.
Let’s consider how the use of payroll software can benefit small businesses, by seeing the top payroll companies you can rely on, and assist you in selecting the best payroll service for your business.
How Payroll Software Transforms the Small Business Life
Small business owners wear all hats—marketing, customer service, and even all the HR tasks. That’s where payroll software comes in to make life a whole lot easier. Let’s take a look at how it can impact your daily routine:
1. Automation of Payroll Functions
Gone are the days of manually calculating salaries. Payroll software automates everything—from tax deductions to direct deposits. This not only saves time but also significantly reduces the chance of errors.
2. Simple Tax Filing
Tax can be stressful, particularly if you’re unsure about the new regulations. Most small business payroll solutions include tax filing.
Meaning your taxes will be completed correctly and filed on time. Some even guarantee accuracy, which gives you peace of mind.
3. Employee Self-Service Sites
All payroll services include employee dashboards. Employees can view pay stubs, tax returns, and personal information without bothering you. This assists employees, and it minimizes your administrative hassles.
4. Compliance Support
Payroll regulations can be complex, but most payroll services assist you in complying with federal, state, and local laws. They automatically notify and remind you if anything happens, so you will always be informed.
5. Simpler Record Keeping
If you have to obtain a pay stub from six months ago or for preparing an audit, payroll software assists you in locating records in a flash. All of this is stored securely and in a tidy manner.
The move to payroll software is very significant. It makes small businesses function more effectively, prevents costly mistakes, and focuses more on expansion.
Top Payroll Companies For Small Business
If you’d prefer to outsource your payroll tasks to specialists, there are several reputable payroll companies to choose from.
Below are ten of the best payroll companies for small businesses to consider:
1. Enthusiasm
Gusto is a favorite among small businesses. It is simple to use, offers complete payroll service, and comes with helpful HR tools. Gusto also offers tax filing, employee benefits, and a useful self-service portal for your employees.
2. Paychex
Paychex is adaptable. If you’re an individual business owner or if you’re operating an expanding workforce, Paychex offers scalable payroll. It also includes onboarding employees and time management.
3. ADP
ADP is a reputable payroll firm for small businesses and has reliable services with excellent customer service. ADP’s mobile app is wonderful, and it makes it easy to manage payroll while you are not around.
4. OnPay
OnPay is best suited for companies that require an easy, full solution. It incorporates payroll, HR, and benefits administration at an affordable cost. Apart from that, it is user-friendly.
5. Intuit QuickBooks Payroll
If you have accounting already established with QuickBooks, it makes sense to add QuickBooks Payroll. You can easily connect your accounting records and have them all in one place. It also has automatic tax calculation.
6. Square Payroll
Square Payroll is ideal for companies already utilizing Square to accept payments. It is inexpensive, easy to use, and suits small groups or companies with hourly employees.
7. SurePayroll
SurePayroll focuses on providing services to small businesses. They offer flexible plans and manage payroll taxes, direct deposit, and compliance with ease. Their customer support is also excellent.
8. Paycor
Paycor provides a modern, cloud-based platform to small businesses who desire something more than payroll. Includes employee scheduling, HR management, and performance tracking.
9. Zenefits
Zenefits is a suitable option if you require an integrated HR and payroll solution. It offers benefits administration, time management, and compliance solutions along with payroll services.
10. Patriot Software
Patriot is affordably priced and perfect for people who need a simple-to-use payroll system with not too much flash. Moreover, Patriot has excellent customer support and transparent, straightforward pricing.
So, if you are looking for payroll providers for a small business, you need to think about what you require.
Some companies will require assistance with HR, while others will just need straightforward payroll at an affordable cost.
What is the optimum payroll for a small business?
The ideal payroll solution is what your company requires the most. Let’s dissect it step by step:
For Easy-to-Use Features:
Firstly, if you prefer something very user-friendly, Gusto or OnPay would be the way to go. They both have clean screens and good support in case you get lost.
For Frugal Businesses:
Secondly, Patriot Software and SurePayroll are reputable for offering good payroll services at reasonable rates. They are good options if you don’t have much money to spend.
For Scaling Teams:
Thirdly, if you need to grow quickly, Paycor and Paychex offer superior features, including employee scheduling, benefits management, and HR assistance. They can grow with your company.
For Integrated Accounting:
Fourthly, if you are already running QuickBooks for your finances, QuickBooks Payroll would be of great assistance to you. The integration of payroll and accounting saves time.
For Hourly Workers:
Lastly, Square Payroll is perfect if you have independent contractors or hourly employees. It is very easy to pay them and monitor their time.
There is not a single best answer for the best small business payroll system. It will depend on your size, budget, and plans for growth.
Most small business payroll firms offer free trials or demos, so you should try a couple of them before you decide.
Things You Should Not Do When Selecting Payroll Services for Small Businesses
When choosing payroll companies for small businesses, you need to know what not to do and what to do. Below are some of the things small business owners ought not to do:
Overlooking Hidden Charge: Some payroll businesses offer low monthly charges but charge additional fees for tax filing, direct deposit, or new hires. Always request the full fee breakdown to prevent surprise charges.
Selecting Complex Systems: A too-complex system will cost you time rather than save you time.
Steer clear of payroll firms that don’t have user-friendly dashboards or straightforward instructions if you’re not tech-savvy.
Overlooking Customer Support: Fast and effective support is required when things go awry. Steer clear of vendors with poor customer support ratings or restricted access to support—you’ll need fast support when things go awry.
Ignores Compliance Assistance: Payroll tax and tax legislation continue to change. Avoid using those firms that do not provide automatic tax compliance or updates.
This may subject your business to fines. By sidestepping these traps, you can reach payroll companies for small businesses that truly meet your needs without unnecessary anxiety.
Payroll Companies For Small Business: Pricing Models
When you’re doing research on payroll firms for small businesses, it’s a good idea to know how cost works so that you can choose a provider that will work for you without surprise.
Most payroll firms have a cost structure that includes two broad fees:
1. Monthly Base Fee
You pay a set amount each month just to use the service. This fee will usually cover the basic payroll software and access to the main features like payment processing and tax calculation.
The minimum fees will differ, usually around $20 to $100 per month, depending on the provider and the service offered.
2. Per-Employee Fee
Apart from the initial fee, payroll firms usually charge a small fraction of a dollar per worker you pay out via their system. The cost can go from $4 to $12 per worker, per month.
Supplementary Expenditures
Certain payroll providers may bill extra for services such as processing end-of-year tax forms, direct deposit, or HR software. Ensure you inquire whether such services are free or extra.
Flat-Rate Alternatives
Certain vendors offer simple, flat-rate plans with no employee-per-head fees, which is beneficial for companies whose staffing fluctuates.
Understanding the pricing model helps small businesses procure inexpensive payroll solutions without neglecting any hidden expenses.
Also read
Related
